Tub-to-Shower Conversion in NYC: Pros, Cons and Resale
Vitutti Construction

Many NYC bathrooms have a standard 5-foot tub that most people use only as a shower. Converting it to a walk-in shower is one of the most common requests we get. Here is how to decide.
The advantages
- Easier access. No climbing over a tub wall, which matters more every year and for anyone with limited mobility.
- A roomier feel. Clear glass and a larger shower make a small bathroom look bigger.
- A modern look. Large tiles, a niche and a bench in place of an old tub surround.
The drawbacks
- Resale in one-bath apartments. Some buyers, especially families with small children, want at least one tub. If it’s your only bathroom, think about who will buy next.
- Cost. A good conversion is more than swapping a fixture: it needs a new drain setup, waterproofing, tile and glass.
A common rule of thumb: in a home with two or more bathrooms, converting one tub is rarely a resale problem. In a one-bathroom apartment, weigh how long you plan to stay.
What the work involves
- removing the tub and the old wall finishes
- adjusting the drain and valve for a shower
- building the shower floor and installing waterproofing
- tile, a niche or bench if wanted, and a glass panel or door
Because the plumbing changes, the work must be done under a Licensed Master Plumber, and depending on the scope a DOB filing may be needed. Your building may also ask for approval. We tell you what applies before work starts.
Curbless or low step?
Where the floor allows it, a curbless walk-in shower gives the cleanest result. Otherwise a low-profile shower base is quicker and still looks modern.
Design ideas for the new shower
- a built-in bench, useful for shaving and for anyone who needs to sit
- a handheld shower on a slide bar alongside the fixed head
- grab bars that match the fixtures, so they look intentional
- a long niche at the old tub height for storage
How long does it take?
A tub-to-shower conversion on its own often takes one to two weeks of work, depending on the plumbing, tile and glass lead time. As part of a full bathroom renovation, it follows the bathroom’s overall schedule.
Get a free estimate
Vitutti Construction is a licensed and insured contractor serving Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens and Long Island. See our bathroom remodeling services or request a free, detailed estimate.
Phone: (914) 339-0804